Hartlepool v Luton: Player ratings as defensive howlers cost Pools dear

Rakish Bingham in action against Luton Town
Rakish Bingham in action against Luton Town
Share this article

Hartlepool United were on the receiving end of a 4-1 defeat to Luton Town.

Reporter Richard Mennear gives his player ratings below as Pools suffered back-to-back defeats.

Adam Bartlett: 5. Could have done better for Hatters opener, parried into path of Smith. Could do little about the others though.

Brad Halliday: 5. Looked more comfortable when Mackail-Smith went off but should have done more to prevent Luton third. Miss-kick at a crucial time.

Scott Harrison: 5. Blasted a free-kick high over the bar first half. Lack of pace shown up for Luton’s second. Poor second half.

Andrew Boyce: 5. Jury still very much out on Boyce. Looked out of sorts and uncomfortable at the back. Another unconvincing display.

Jake Carroll: 5. Still much more to come from the left-back. Off day all round for the defence.

Connor Smith: 6. Rapid pace and he started brightly winning a free-kick. Works hard and kept grafting.

Carl Magnay: 6. Back in the side and marshalled the area in front of the defence after Mackail-Smith had gone off. One of Pools’ better players.

Michael Woods: 6. Quiet afternoon for Woods but Kept play ticking over.

Rhys Oates: 6. Worked hard down the left wing and provided the assist for Paynter’s equaliser. Poor crossing second half though.

Billy Paynter: 6. Captain Paynter came up trumps with 45th minute equaliser, linked up well with Bingham and showed a range of passing. Went off as a precaution second half.

Rakish Bingham: 5. Should have scored a hat-trick, had several good chances. Tyler made one fine stop to deny him first half. Needs to find form fast.


Scott Fenwick: 6. Didn’t really trouble the Hatters defence.

Nicky Featherstone: 6. Blasted a good opening wide late on.

Goals: Paynter (44)

Luton Town:

Mark Tyler: 8

Scott Cuthbert: 6

Scott Griffiths: 6

Steve McNulty (C): 6

Luke Wilkinson: 7

Jonathan Smith: 7

Ollie Lee: 8

Luke Guttridge: 6

Josh McQuoid: 6 (Doyle, 80, 6)

Cameron McGeehan: 6

Craig Mackail-Smith, 6 (Marriott, 28, 8).

Goals: Smith (17), Marriott (53, 57), Lee (91)


Richard Clark (Northumberland) Kept the game flowing...6/10