Hartlepool driver wins £170 parking penalty battle after claiming signage was incorrect

A motorist has successfully fought off a £170 penalty issued at a Hartlepool car park after an 18-month long battle with the parking company.

Paul Barton refused to pay the penalty charge he was given after using the Belle Vue Way shopping parade in August 2024.

He challenged the penalty by arguing the wording on signage in the car park was incorrect as it was subsequently changed.

Mr Barton was set to contest the charge in court later this month.

Paul Barton with the letter confirming the parking company is no longer pursuing him against one of the newer parking signs.placeholder image
Paul Barton with the letter confirming the parking company is no longer pursuing him against one of the newer parking signs.

But legal representatives acting for the company Parking Group Limited wrote to him saying the case had been dropped.

Mr Barton believes many other drivers may also have been penalised incorrectly.

He said: “It’s all wrong what they do.”

Mr Barton, a sales manager, visited the car park, which is for customers using units 1-6 Belle Vue Way, in a Skoda Scala in August 2024.

The customer car park for units 1-6 Belle Vue Way, Hartlepool.placeholder image
The customer car park for units 1-6 Belle Vue Way, Hartlepool.

He stopped outside Greggs while dropping his partner off and briefly nipped inside for a coffee.

But he later received a penalty for £100, reduced to £60 if paid promptly, for not parking in a marked bay. It later increased to £170.

Mr Barton, 61, said: “I was literally in and out in a minute.

“I hadn’t realised this company had only just started managing the car park.”

On subsequent examination of the signs, he argued the wording on the original was unclear as one of stipulations referred to drivers observing terms and conditions “above”.

Yet the only wording above simply stated drivers had to remain on the site while parked there.

New signs with a different design, emphasising that people must park in marked bays, were installed around August last year.

Mr Barton refused to pay despite repeated demands and letters from the parking company’s legal representatives.

He added: “I hadn’t left the site and thought ‘I haven’t broken any rules’.”

He was prepared to contest the issue at a small claims court hearing on Monday, March 16, and had enlisted the services of a barrister.

But Mr Barton was written to by DCB Legal, which represent Parking Group Limited, last month stating: “Our client has instructed us to discontinue court proceedings and close our file.”

The Mail has contacted Parking Group Limited for comment.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice