Jeff Stelling asks: Who is the greatest Hartlepool United player of them all?

Watch more of our videos on ShotsTV.com 
and on Freeview 262 or Freely 565
Visit Shots! now
I am in the middle of my third theatre tour of the UK with my old Soccer Saturday friend/foe Bianca Westwood.

This run has taken us to some proper football towns – Grimsby, Exeter, Peterborough, Wrexham, Morecambe and many more.

The thing I enjoy most is the kinship between supporters of lower league sides.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

We have had a brilliant welcome everywhere and everyone wants to talk about contests between their team and Pools over the years.

Clockwise from top left, Hartlepool United greats Ritchie Humphreys, Nicky Featherstone, Jimmy Mulvaney and Brian Honour.Clockwise from top left, Hartlepool United greats Ritchie Humphreys, Nicky Featherstone, Jimmy Mulvaney and Brian Honour.
Clockwise from top left, Hartlepool United greats Ritchie Humphreys, Nicky Featherstone, Jimmy Mulvaney and Brian Honour.

In Peterborough, they wanted to know if I remembered a 4-4 draw in the early 80s.

I didn’t but reminded them of us going to London Road in 2003 and winning 4-3. And returning in 2006 and winning 5-3.

Morecambe fans wanted to talk about the bald headed, bludgeoner Kevin Ellison who always tormented us.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

When he scored against us in 2014 in what was a must win game in our battle against relegation, their travelling supporters taunted me with “Stelling, Stelling what’s the score?”

Rob McKinnon, left, and Brian Honour are among the Hartlepool United legends mentioned by Jeff Stelling as contenders for the club's greatest player.Rob McKinnon, left, and Brian Honour are among the Hartlepool United legends mentioned by Jeff Stelling as contenders for the club's greatest player.
Rob McKinnon, left, and Brian Honour are among the Hartlepool United legends mentioned by Jeff Stelling as contenders for the club's greatest player.

When Jack Compton and Jack Barmby scored late on to win the match for us – even though we were down to 10 men – I stood in the directors box, to give a one man response of “Morecambe, Morecambe what’s the score?“

A lot of Wrexham fans wanted to remind me of Juan Ugarte’s amazing feat of scoring five at the Vic in a 6-4 win.

Grimsby supporters wanted to talk about Gav Holohan.

It is a real trip down Memory Lane.

In Rhyl, one fan asked me who was Hartlepool’s greatest ever player.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

That got me thinking. I can go back to the 60s when Ernie Phythian, alongside his fellow striker Jimmy Mulvaney, were terrorising Division Four defences.

Brian Drysdale and later Rob McKinnon were exceptional full-backs.

Brian Honour had a decade at the club giving absolutely everything – and then a bit more.

I will never forget the bottle Ritchie Humphreys showed when scoring the decisive penalty

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

in a shoot-out in a play-off semi-final at Tranmere, having missed one at Cheltenham in an earlier play-off game.

There were the memorable strikers like Bob Newton and Adam Boyd – who could forget his hat-trick in what were near water-polo conditions against Sheffield Wednesday?

I loved our Greek keeper Dimi Konstantopoulos, the Australian magic man, Joel Porter and, for obvious reasons, James Brown.

For me, Nicky Featherstone has also earned the right to be included among Pools’ greatest.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It made me think who of the current squad bar Nicky might stake a claim in future.

If Anthony Mancini could stay fit, he certainly has the talent, though it is a big "if”.

The home game against Oldham was a clear reminder of his abilities.

We could have done with him against Woking on Saturday to try and unlock their defence.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

I am looking forward to Portsmouth, Crewe, Ipswich, Shrewsbury and many more places where I am sure my trip down Memory Lane will continue.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
©National World Publishing Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice