Concerns over alcohol sales plan at former methodist church building

Councillors are preparing to rule on proposals to grant a licence for a new convenience store due to open at the previous home of Thornley Methodist Church, in Dunelm Road, Thornley.

But while some neighbours raised fears of plans to allow booze sales as late as 11pm, backers have pointed to a lack of objection from police and other authorities to back their case.

“We don’t think the sale of alcohol is going to cause crime and disorder,” said Robert Botkai, a solicitor acting for the applicant.

“No one has a crystal ball, but there is no evidence that it will happen or that it is likely to happen.

“If the committee is minded to grant the licence and that results in problems, the residents have the power to put an application in for a review of the licence.

“I hope that won’t happen – I hope what will happen is that if there are any problems will communicate so discussions can be had and steps taken.”

Botkai was speaking at a November 23 meeting of Durham County Council’s Statutory Licensing Sub-Committee, which was held by videolink and broadcast via YouTube.

Planning permission for the former church to be demolished to make way for the shop, which will be part of the Jack’s franchise run by Tesco, were approved in June (2020).

An application was also submitted to the county council’s licensing department to open and sell alcohol from 7am – 11pm, seven days a week.

Following consultation however, Sunday and Bank Holiday hours were reduced to 9am – 4pm.

Written objections were submitted by Thornley Parish Council, citing ‘numerous objections’ and fears the store will ‘create disturbance and lead to antisocial behaviour’.

Speaking to the committee directly, one objector, named in paperwork as Mrs Brandling, claimed the hours proposed were not an ‘acceptable time to sell alcohol’ and suggested sales should instead be forced to stop at between 8.30-9pm.

After hearing evidence, Cllr David Bell, temporarily took charge to end the meeting after Cllr Linda Marshall, the panel’s chairman, lost connection to the online proceedings.

Cllr Bell, Cllr Marshall and Cllr Karon Liddell retired to consider the application.

A decision is expected later.

Support your Echo and become a subscriber today. Enjoy unlimited access to local news, the latest on SAFC and new puzzles every day. With a digital subscription, you can see fewer ads, enjoy faster load times, and get access to exclusive newsletters and content. Click here to subscribe.