Hartlepool United manager insists referee's decision to book Alex Reid for diving during Aldershot Town defeat 'didn't make sense'

Hartlepool United manager Nicky Featherstone said referee Kavan Hurn's decision to book striker Alex Reid for simulation during the second half of Saturday's 3-0 drubbing at home to relegation-threatened Aldershot Town "didn't make sense".

With Pools trailing 2-0 against a Shots side who arrived at Victoria Park with one of the division's worst defensive records and desperate for a route back into the game, Reid broke forward with 14 minutes remaining before going down inside the area following a sliding challenge from the retreating Olly Scott.

Pools boss Nicky Featherstone insists that referee Kavan Hurn's decision to book Alex Reid for diving following Olly Scott's sliding challenge towards the end of Saturday's heavy defeat at home to Aldershot "didn't make sense". Picture by Frank Reid.placeholder image
Pools boss Nicky Featherstone insists that referee Kavan Hurn's decision to book Alex Reid for diving following Olly Scott's sliding challenge towards the end of Saturday's heavy defeat at home to Aldershot "didn't make sense". Picture by Frank Reid.

With Pools fans - and, indeed, Reid - vociferously appealing for a penalty, Hurn instead opted to award the visitors a free-kick before giving the experienced frontman a yellow card for diving. Whether or not the 30-year-old, who has scored seven goals in 25 games since sealing a summer move from Oldham, was a little unfortunate is very much up for debate. While home fans certainly seemed to feel Pools should have been awarded a penalty, on first glance it appeared as though the outstanding Scott had taken at least some of the ball; perhaps, therefore, the right decision might have been to award the hosts a corner.

Whatever the case, Pools failed to score for the 10th time in 30 National League matches and it is debatable whether the award of a penalty would have changed the game enough for them to salvage a result, while it's also worth remembering that decisions went in their favour during narrow home wins over Altrincham, when Featherstone's side were given a very questionable late penalty, and Gateshead, when Louis Storey was sent off with the visitors leading 1-0.

"I've just seen a different angle but it's difficult to tell, you can't really see it from the angle," Featherstone said.

"I don't see why he goes down if he's got a clear shot on goal. At the time I thought it was a penalty, but I don't know, I haven't spoken to Reidy (Reid) about it. It didn't make sense to me for Reidy to go down if he's one-on-one with the keeper."

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice