Hartlepool United manager Nicky Featherstone has his say on National League's '3UP' campaign
Hartlepool United manager Nicky Featherstone has thrown his support behind the National League's '3UP' campaign.
The National League's call for the introduction of a third promotion place from the fifth tier into League Two has been steadily gathering momentum and is now being backed by a whole host of famous faces and big names from throughout the footballing - and, indeed, wider - world. Hartlepool United fan and renowned broadcaster Jeff Stelling has argued that the absence of a third promotion place from the National League is "shameful", while influential sports writer Michael Keegan slammed it as "absolutely ludicrous". Legendary manager Neil Warnock, meanwhile, said the introduction of a third promotion place was "common sense" and that it was "only fear" preventing clubs in the Football League coming out in its favour.
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer commended the efforts of campaigners, while 60 MPs have back the idea. Hartlepool's labour MP Jonathan Brash, who is a Pools fan, led an Adjournment Debate in the House of Commons on the issue last month. He described '3UP' as "not a radical restructuring of football" but "a straightforward reform to make the system fairer, more competitive and more sustainable".
The case for the introduction of a third promotion place was brought into sharp focus by the plight of York City last season. The Minstermen finished second in the National League after amassing a whopping 96 points but missed out on promotion back to the Football League after losing to eventual winners Oldham Athletic in the play-off semi-finals. In the end, the Latics clinched promotion despite finishing three places and a staggering 23 points behind York, prompting Julie-Anne and Matthew Uggla, the co-owners of the Minstermen, to pen an open letter to the Football League that slammed the current promotion system as "unjust" and "no longer fit for purpose".


While it's true that the case of York might well be an extreme example, there are a whole host of other sides who have succumbed to the National League's notoriously high bar when it comes to winning promotion. Indeed, over the last decade just three of the 10 second-placed finishers have gone on to win promotion via the play-offs, meaning the likes of Barnet, Wrexham, Torquay United, Solihull Moors and Tranmere Rovers have all missed out in similarly agonising fashion to York. Since 2015/16, second-placed teams have averaged 87.5 points per season, whereas eventual play-off winners have averaged six fewer at 81.3.
Although in the past the argument against the introduction of a third promotion place into the Football League has tended to focus on an apparent gap in quality between League Two and the National League, statistical evidence suggests that no longer holds any weight. Indeed, of the 19 clubs to have been promoted over the last 10 seasons - Grimsby have achieved the feat twice - only four, including Pools, are not still competing in the Football League.
In fact, four of the 15 teams still competing in the Football League are now playing at a higher level than League Two, with Lincoln City, Leyton Orient and Stockport County in League One while Wrexham won promotion to the Championship last season. Bromley, who won the National League play-offs in 2024, are currently top of League Two, while Notts County, who were made to sweat through a penalty shootout in the 2023 play-offs despite finishing the regular season with 107 points, are hot on their heels in fourth.
A Football Supporters' Association survey carried out last year suggested overwhelming support for the National League's 3UP campaign, with 93 per cent of fans in agreement with the principle of three up, three down. Remarkably, 77 per cent of fans who support a League Two team - that is, teams who would be made more vulnerable to relegation by the change - were in favour of the introduction of a third promotion and relegation place between the two divisions. So, with so much support from such a wide spectrum, what is holding things back?
Well, in order for a change to be made, it has to be voted on and ratified by clubs in the Football League and, as the argument goes, that's like asking turkeys to vote for Christmas. Positive talks have been held between the National League and the Football League and the EFL have previously said that the issue is being debated by its members "at regular intervals, most recently in the past few months". While there does appear to be growing support for the initiative from the Football League - the National League's vice-chairman, Steve Thompson, has said that "an awful lot" of EFL clubs privately support the campaign but "won't put their heads above the parapet" - it would appear that not everyone is convinced. Lincoln City chairman Clive Nates, for example, said that "the situation is more complicated than many wish to admit".
Having played in both the Football League and the National League throughout his long career, current Pools boss Featherstone is well-placed to have his say on the ongoing debate. With Pools still just about in the race for a place in the National League play-offs this season, Featherstone has thrown his support behind the initiative.
"100 per cent I'd be in favour, especially in our position - absolutely, bring it in," he said.
"I think it should be in anyway. Last season, York ended up on 96 points, Oldham finished on 73 and they beat York in the play-offs; Oldham went up with 23 points less, nothing against them but that isn't fair.
"I think the reward needs to be there. Look at this season, teams are going to end up on over 100 points and some of them aren't going to go up. I like the play-off format still but I think there should be an extra team that goes up, definitely.
"The difference between the top end of the National League and League Two is getting smaller and smaller. I think you'd also find that the clubs that come down have a much better opportunity of bouncing back a bit quicker.
"The reward should be for a season's worth of work rather than just a play-off campaign, York were so hard done by last year. There has to be a reward there and from the club's point of view and from my point of view, an extra promotion place would be lovely."
Your next Hartlepool United read: Hartlepool United manager insists Pools still looking to strengthen squad