Interim manager Keith Curle called upon Umerah from the bench with little under 30 minutes remaining with Hartlepool 2-0 down at the One Call Stadium.
Quickfire goals from George Lapslie and Riley Harbottle inside the opening 15 minutes of the second half gave Curle’s side a mountain to climb.
But, having made the bold decision to leave Umerah out of his starting XI, Curle turned to the 25-year-old who gave the perfect response to being left out.
Umerah gave Pools a lifeline with almost his first touch of the game when capitalising on Harbottle’s loose back-pass to round Christy Pym and find the far corner.
And Umerah would celebrate his fifth goal for Pools a minute from time when latching onto Alex Lacey’s direct ball to slide beyond Pym and earn an unlikely point.
And here is how Pools were rated.

13. Brody Paterson - 5
Struggled to offer much protection to Ferguson as Mansfield continued to be a threat down that side. Might have done better with clearance for Harbottle strike. (Credit: Tom West | MI News) Photo: Tom West

14. Josh Umerah - 9
Superb cameo from the bench and the perfect response to being dropped. Put himself about, worked the channels and showed great composure for both goals and almost pinched a winner at the end. Fully expect him to return to the XI on Tuesday. (Credit: Mark Fletcher | MI News) Photo: Mark Fletcher

15. Jack Hamilton - NA
Came on for the final 15 minutes as Pools threw a little bit of caution to the wind with more bodies up top and he played his part in that. (Credit: Tom West | MI News) Photo: Tom West

16. Clarke Oduor - NA
Came on for Sylla in the final minute of normal time. Looked a threat on the counter-attack in the closing stages. (Credit: Tom West | MI News) Photo: Tom West

