How will former owner Raj Singh be remembered following Hartlepool United takeover by American businessman?

American businessman and investor Landon Smith completed a surprise takeover of Hartlepool United on New Year's Eve, bringing to an end former owner Raj Singh's almost eight years at the helm.

Even Singh's most passionate supporters would struggle to argue that his tenure hasn't been blighted by division, discontent and disappointment, both on and off the pitch. Even so, it's easy to forget but there were some good spells under the 61-year-old while his decision to intervene in 2018 was among the most consequential in the club's entire history.

Had things been different, Singh could well be saying goodbye to Victoria Park as the universally acclaimed saviour of Hartlepool United. After all, his takeover of the club as well as his commitment of around £1.2 million effectively helped to stave off the threat of looming administration and even potential footballing oblivion.

Prior to Singh – which given all the tumult and drama of the last few years must feel to many fans like a lifetime ago - Pools were in the midst of a potentially catastrophic period and there was a growing sense that the club was teetering on the edge of a precipice. Who could forget, for instance, the outpouring of anger that followed the club's first ever relegation out of the Football League in 2017 as well as the chaos, uncertainty and occasional humiliation that characterised their first season in the National League?

Raj Singh's almost eight years as Hartlepool United owner have been blighted by controversy, division and discontent among an increasingly fractured fanbase. Picture by Frank Reid.placeholder image
Raj Singh's almost eight years as Hartlepool United owner have been blighted by controversy, division and discontent among an increasingly fractured fanbase. Picture by Frank Reid.

Pools struggled to keep up with their gas and electric bills, couldn't afford to get their kits back from the dry cleaners, while times were so bad that then-manager Craig Harrison's wife provided the team's matchday meals. Whatever fans might think of Singh, he stepped in to pull Pools from the mire and without doubt established them on a much firmer financial footing.

More than that, Singh led Pools back to the Football League in 2021, winning a memorable promotion via the National League play-offs under Dave Challinor, while also overseeing runs to the fourth round of the FA Cup as well as the semi-finals of the Football League Trophy. For many fans, these will long be remembered as among the greatest days of their lives. Without Singh, they simply wouldn't have been possible.

Yet a lot of the goodwill Singh worked so hard to build up has evaporated since then, with the final years of his tenure overshadowed by almost unparalleled division and discontent amongst a fanbase once considered among the most united in the country. Without wishing to lose sight of the financial progress made under Singh, in purely footballing terms Pools are little better off than they were back in 2018.

Having won promotion back to League Two and acquitted themselves well back in the big time, Singh's failure to keep hold of Dave Challinor as well as his calamitous decision to appoint Paul Hartley as manager in the summer of 2022 led to Pools being relegated back to the National League after just two seasons in the Football League.

Since then, Pools have limped to successive mid-table finishes and the final 12 months of Singh's tenure, in particular, saw many fans lose faith in his leadership altogether, with attendances dwindling since the start of the 2025-26 season as sections of supporters chose to stay away from Victoria Park in protest at his ownership. Not to mention the sheer volume of managers that have passed through.

Singh's decision to resign from his role as chairman in March last year followed by his remarkable return in the wake of the apparent collapse of takeover negotiations involving Herd International Group, led by Hartlepool-born businesswoman Shelley Hammond, following a hugely contested vote among season ticket holders was the final straw for many fans.

Pools were previously linked with a whole host of takeover bids, from Hollywood stars Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney - something Singh has always strongly denied - to the one involving a mystery consortium that was being brokered with the help of the Hartlepool United Supporters' Trust.

Now, however, Singh has surprised fans by completing a takeover with the American Smith, co-founder of real estate company Tailwind Group, in a deal that took around six weeks from start to finish. If - and there is of course no guarantee that change will lead to success - Smith can help bring fans back to Victoria Park and lead Pools to the Football League, then history might well still look kindly on Singh.

While the tumult and turbulence of Singh's tenure will not easily be forgotten, neither will his intervention to save the club in 2018. Singh's legacy will certainly be hotly debated and it is impossible to ignore some of the mistakes made both on the pitch and in the boardroom, but the outgoing owner deserves credit for, albeit somewhat unexpectedly, giving Hartlepool United fans reason to believe once again.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice