We posed that question to our readers and, after hundreds of responses, we’ve put together what Hartlepool fans believe to be the best line-up currently at Challinor’s disposal.
As usual, there were a few interesting choices. Scroll down and click through the pages to reveal the squad selected by Pools supporters!
1. GK: Ben Killip
With 77% of the vote, the fans' choice in goal is Ben Killip. The Pools number 1 hasn't featured in the side in 2020 with Mitchell Beeney coming in. If Poolies had their way, the England C international would be first choice in between the sticks. Photo: Frank Reid
2. LB: Mark Kitching
With 79% of the vote, Kitching is first choice at left-back as he has been all season. With 255 votes to his name, the 24-year-old doesn't have too much in the way of competition with Myles Anderson receiving the next highest number of votes with 32. Photo: Mark Fletcher
3. CB: Gary Liddle
Far and away the first choice at centre-back for fans is Gary Liddle, receiving a whopping 87% of the vote. The Walsall loanee has settled back in well since returning to the club until the end of the season. Photo: Frank Reid
4. CB: Timi Odusina
Despite only playing two matches for Pools to date, Norwich City loanee Timi Odusina is fans' second choice at centre-back. The youngster came second behind Liddle as first choice centre-back with 7% of the vote but was the clear front runner in the second choice vote with 50%. Photo: Jacques Feeney