Is Gavan Holohan's return the right move for Hartlepool United?
Hartlepool United completed their second signing of the Landon Smith era on Tuesday afternoon, welcoming experienced midfielder Gavan Holohan back to Victoria Park.
Of course, the Irishman is well known to Pools fans having scored 21 goals in 106 games during a hugely successful earlier spell in the North East.
Indeed, Holohan was an integral part of the Pools side that won a memorable promotion back to the Football League via a heart-stopping National League play-off final under Dave Challinor in 2021, finding the net eight times in 44 matches.
During the 2020/21 season in particular, Holohan combined with Mark Shelton and current Pools boss Nicky Featherstone to comprise the so-called midfield 'wolf pack', with the trio becoming renowned for their reliability, robustness, hard work without the ball, tough-tackling, commitment and ability in possession.


Holohan went on to write himself into Hartlepool United folklore once again the following season, scoring a late winner on the opening day of the 2021/22 campaign - the club's first game back in the Football League for three years - as well as a sensational goal to secure three points against rivals Carlisle later in August as Pools really began to make their mark on League Two.
However, Holohan fell out of favour after Challinor, who left to take charge of Stockport County in November, was replaced by Graeme Lee. For whatever reason, the new Pools boss didn't seem to fancy the 34-year-old and he soon fell down the pecking order before being allowed to leave in order to sign for Grimsby in March 2022.
It didn't take the veteran long to make his mark in North East Lincolnshire, scoring a last minute equaliser against Notts County in the National League play-off semi-final two months after his arrival - the Mariners would go on to win the game 2-1 in extra time - before featuring as Grimsby won promotion back to the Football League, the second time Holohan had achieved the feat in two years.
Much like he did at Pools, the attack-minded midfielder established himself as a folk hero at Blundell Park, scoring two penalties in a remarkable 2-1 win over Southampton, then of the Premier League, as the Mariners reached the quarter-finals of the FA Cup for the first time since 1939.
Just when it seemed like his stock had never been higher, however, Holohan was released by Grimsby in the summer of 2024 and a subsequent spell at Crawley never really felt like working out. Indeed, the former Drogheda, Cork, Galway and Waterford man leaves the West Sussex side having made just 12 starts in the league, with the Red Devils scrapping for their lives at the wrong end of League Two and in a desperate battle to avoid back-to-back relegations.
So, while Pools fans - and, indeed, Featherstone - know all about Holohan's various qualities, it remains to be seen whether he will be able to make a similar sort of impact at Victoria Park this time around, almost four years after he left for the first time.
Certainly, Pools have been on the hunt for an attacking-midfielder to provide a link between the engine room and the front line, with Featherstone repeatedly suggesting his squad needed new additions in the wake of American businessman and investor Smith's takeover of the club on New Year's Eve.
Goals have been a big issue for Pools all season, with Featherstone's side finding the net a meagre 32 times in 29 National League matches - league leaders York, for example, have scored a whopping 74 goals in 28 games - and drawing a blank on nine separate occasions this term. Pools are the lowest scorers in the top half of the National League and just five sides throughout the division have managed fewer goals; three of those - Braintree, Truro and Gateshead - are in the relegation zone.
While it would be easy to point the finger at misfiring strikers - although Alex Reid, who has scored seven goals in 24 National League appearances, has made a reasonable start to life at Victoria Park, Danny Johnson has endured a torrid time and is without a goal in any of his first 28 matches this term - Pools have also been lacking a creative presence in midfield.
The likes of Nathan Sheron and Jack Hunter are, as fans have often pointed out, a similar profile of player renowned more for their defensive qualities than their goalscoring prowess, while Jamie Miley is still finding his way and probably hasn't contributed as much in the final third as supporters might have hoped during his first full season in the North East.
Featherstone, then, will be hoping that Holohan can be the man to bridge the gap between midfield and attack, providing some much-needed support for Reid up front while also impacting the game both with and without the ball.
What's more, Holohan knows exactly what it takes to get out of the National League having won promotion with Pools and Grimsby, while the Irishman boasts huge experience and has scored 65 goals in 414 appearances throughout his long career in Ireland and England. For Featherstone, the new recruit's impact in terms of "raising standards and expectations within the squad every single day" could be just as important as what he provides on the pitch.
Yet it's also true that, at 34, Holohan is unlikely to be the same player he was during his first spell at Victoria Park, when he was renowned for his dogged determination and relentless hard work. Indeed, his arrival doesn't exactly align with the club's new emphasis on a data-driven, analytical approach to recruitment that Pools hope will deliver more sustained success thanks to taking a longer term view. In fact, Holohan is almost the exact opposite of that given his age - the Irishman has signed, initially at least, on a short-term deal until the end of the season - as well as his links with the Pools boss, who must surely have played an outsize role in bringing him back to Victoria Park.
Even so, that doesn't have to be a bad thing and the fact that Featherstone - or, indeed, whoever is in charge at Pools - will still hold considerable influence when it comes to recruitment must surely rank as a positive. For all data has the potential to be a powerful tool and will, hopefully, increase the club's success rate in the transfer market, it's almost impossibly to quantify personal qualities like character and commitment; Pools, therefore, will have to strike the right balance between trusting the data and maintaining faith in good, old-fashioned human judgement.
The next few weeks are likely to give fans an indication of the club's policy when it comes to recruitment, with Pools also having been strongly linked with a move for Carlisle attacking-midfielder Stephen Wearne. At 25, the Stockton-born attacker would feel like a signing with much more of a long-term view in mind and it remains to be seen whether Holohan's arrival means there is no longer room for Wearne in the squad.
With the mercurial Jermaine Francis having completed a permanent move to Sutton and Ashley Nathaniel-George returning to York following the expiration of his decidedly underwhelming loan, however, fans - and, in all likelihood, Featherstone - will be hoping there's scope for further attacking reinforcements. The signing of Wearne - or someone of a similar ilk - has the potential to be a real statement of intent from Pools.
For now, Pools turn their attention to Saturday's visit of strugglers Aldershot and what promises to be an emotional homecoming for Holohan. While the club are eager to prove that data and a new way of doing things will help lead to sustained success, Pools are now hoping that a certain Irish midfielder can help inspire them back to the Football League.
Your next Hartlepool United read: HUFC complete dramatic return of star midfielder Gavan Holohan