The curious case of Peter Hartley: could Hartlepool United revisit pursuit of former skipper as hunt for new manager enters second month?

In the latest twist in Hartlepool United's hunt for a new manager, former Pools skipper Peter Hartley, who had appeared to be among the leading contenders to replace Simon Grayson, took to social media to rule himself out of the running.

In a since-deleted post on X, the 37-year-old, who made 188 appearances at Victoria Park across two separate spells, wrote that he had "decided to step back for now" and that "sometimes timing, structure and focus need to align perfectly to achieve success".

The former Pools skipper, who was born in Hartlepool and had seemed to be among the leading contenders to land the vacant manager's job at Victoria Park, appeared to rule himself out of the running in a since-deleted social media post last week. Picture by Mark Fletcher.placeholder image
The former Pools skipper, who was born in Hartlepool and had seemed to be among the leading contenders to land the vacant manager's job at Victoria Park, appeared to rule himself out of the running in a since-deleted social media post last week. Picture by Mark Fletcher.

The defender, who also turned out for the likes of Stevenage, Plymouth and Motherwell, had been among the favorites to become the 14th permanent appointment of controversial chairman and owner Raj Singh's divisive tenure after the Hartlepool Mail revealed the club had spoken to Hartley, interim boss Nicky Featherstone, who has led Pools to eight points from their last four National League games, as well as first team coach Elliot Dickman about the vacant manager's job.

Whether Pools could go back in for Hartley, who has been a member of the coaching staff at Scottish Premiership side St Mirren since October 2024, remains to be seen although it's understood that the club have made contact with him since his social media post, which has been taken down.

It's now been more than a month since Singh made the surprise decision to sack Grayson after just 15 games at the helm.

While a run of just one win in 11 matches had seen Pools slide out of the play-off places, the decision came as a shock to many fans after Singh and the board appeared to provide the new boss with significant financial and moral backing during one of the most turbulent summer's in the club's history.

Having made the decision to dispense with Grayson, who became the 12th of Singh's 13 permanent appointments to fail to survive for a year in the role as well as the fifth in succession to be leave after 17 games or fewer, some sections of supporters have criticised the club's apparent lack of forward planning and foresight.

Pools have been linked with a whole host of potential candidates, from club legend Antony Sweeney, who is understood not to be in the running despite emerging as the surprise bookmakers' favourite over the weekend, to former Morecambe manager Derek Adams, who was appointed as the new director of football at League One strugglers Plymouth earlier this week.

What is becoming increasingly clear is that either Pools did not have a plan regarding who should replace Grayson, who told BBC Radio Tees Sport he was frustrated and disappointed with his sudden dismissal, or that the club have been rebuffed by most or all of their initial preferred candidates.

At this stage, it would seem that Featherstone, who has overseen an upturn in his side's form and knows the club like the back of his hand having spent more than a decade at Victoria Park, looks to be the likeliest man to take on the role on a permanent basis.

The 37-year-old, who is the club's third highest appearance-maker of all-time, has made a positive impression in the dugout despite a difficult start as Pools were knocked out of the FA Cup in abject fashion by Northern Premier League Premier Division side Gainsborough Trinity in his first game in interim charge.

While the veteran midfielder has been aided by a run of favourable fixtures - three of their last four matches have been against sides in the bottom half of the National League table - both results and performances have improved while Saturday's battling win over play-off chasing Halifax, the highlight of Featherstone's tenure so far, moved Pools to within three points of the play-off places.

Although Featherstone admitted he didn't know whether he would still be in charge ahead of Saturday's visit of in-form Wealdstone amidst rumours Pools have held talks with former Altrincham boss Phil Parkinson, there remains a sense that he is in pole position to become the club's next permanent manager.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice