Where do Hartlepool United need to strengthen if Pools are to mount a National League play-off push?

Hartlepool United manager Nicky Featherstone revealed on Saturday that he expects Pools to move to strengthen their squad this week.

With Pools still in with a fighting chance of sneaking into the National League play-off places this season following a run of three matches unbeaten, one or even several new recruits could well be the difference between a top seven finish or another season of mid-table mediocrity.

While it was always going to be tough for Pools to compete with big-spenders such as York, who are now top of the National League having won their last two games by an aggregate score of 8-0, Carlisle and Forest Green Rovers, the likes of Boreham Wood, who were only promoted from the National League South via the play-offs last season but sit third following a remarkable campaign so far, and Scunthorpe, who are hot on the Hertfordshire side's heels in their first season back in the fifth tier, have proven that having one of the biggest budgets isn't the only way to be successful.

It's still not quite clear where Pools are likely to sit in terms of financial pulling power following American businessman and investor Landon Smith's takeover of the club on New Year's Eve. In all likelihood, Pools are not going to be able to outspend many of their better resourced rivals but there is nonetheless hope that a fresh injection of investment could provide Featherstone's side with a shot in the arm between now and the end of the season.

With Hartlepool United still within touching distance of the National League play-off places, one or even several new recruits could be the difference between Pools sneaking into the top seven or finishing in mid-table for the third successive campaign. Picture by Frank Reid.placeholder image
With Hartlepool United still within touching distance of the National League play-off places, one or even several new recruits could be the difference between Pools sneaking into the top seven or finishing in mid-table for the third successive campaign. Picture by Frank Reid.

Of course, success in the notoriously competitive National League can hinge as much on how well sides spend their budgets as how much cash clubs have to splash. It's true that the likes of Stockport, Wrexham, Notts County and Chesterfield, all sides with considerable financial war chests, have won promotion back to the Football League in recent years. Even so, it's also worth pointing out that Bromley, who currently sit top of League Two, and Barnet, who were crowned National League champions last season after amassing more than 100 points, have achieved success with far more modest resources.

The Ravens and the Bees - as well as a whole host of other National League clubs - have been successful after managing to outthink, outwit and outplan some of their wealthier rivals. Pools, then, could do well to draw on their experiences - and the early signs are that Smith is eager to do so.

Earlier this month, Featherstone revealed that Pools are beginning to implement a more analytical, data-driven approach to recruitment as the club look to move away from the scattergun, reactive policy that's led to more misses than hits over the last few years. There has often been a sense that Pools have recruited as and when the need arises throughout the season, often moving to plug gaps at short notice. While Pools have still managed to unearth some gems in this manner - Reyes Cleary, who was so impressive on loan at Victoria Park last season, is now being valued at around £5 million by League One Barnsley - the club have often found themselves lumbered with players who either aren't good enough or soon become surplus to requirements.

As a result, Pools have often had to contend with a remarkably high turnover of players - the club welcomed 13 new additions under Simon Grayson last summer, while a number of new recruits were added in the opening weeks and months of the campaign - and there has been an almost total lack of long-term planning.

Now, the new regime will have to strike a careful balance between planning for the future - that is to say this summer and the 2026/27 campaign - as well as making sure that, in Smith's own words, "this season still matters". Pools, then, will be on the hunt for new signings that can both help propel them towards the play-off places this season and make an impact next term.

The area most in need of obvious redress is the final third, with Pools among the National League's lowest scorers having found the net a meagre 32 times in 29 matches so far this term. Indeed, Saturday's goalless draw with a resolute and well-organised Brackley side was the ninth league game this season in which Featherstone's side have drawn a blank.

True, Pools need more from their strikers. Having lost Mani Dieseruvwe, who scored 43 goals in 89 games during a prolific spell at Victoria Park, over the summer, Pools turned to Alex Reid, whose 17 goals in 32 National League appearances helped Wealdstone beat the drop last season, and Danny Johnson in a bid to replace their departing talisman. While Reid has made a reasonable enough start to life at Victoria Park, finding the net seven times in 24 league games, Johnson has endured a nightmarish time so far this term and is without a goal in any of his first 28 Pools appearances.

Pools might, therefore, be tempted to bring in a new number nine in a bid to lighten some of the load on Reid, although that might well hinge on Johnson potentially leaving the club on loan in a bid to rebuild some of his confidence in front of goal. Featherstone, however, seems set on signing a new attack-minded midfielder to bridge the gaping gap between attack and midfield that has plagued Pools for large parts of this season.

While Pools have some decent options at their disposal in the engine room, the likes of Nathan Sheron, Jack Hunter and, to a lesser extent, Jamie Miley are all similar sorts of players who are renowned more for reliability and robustness than creativity or goalscoring prowess. If Pools can add a more forward-thinking player to their ranks over the coming weeks, then it could well bring the best out of their current midfield options as well as their forward line.

Featherstone admitted earlier this month that Pools are weighing up potential deals for former midfielder Gavan Holohan, who scored 21 goals in 106 games during a hugely successful first spell at Victoria Park during which he formed an integral part of the side that won promotion back to the Football League under Dave Challinor, as well as out of favour Carlisle attacker Stephen Wearne.

While Pools fans - and, indeed, Featherstone, who was part of the so-called midfield 'wolf pack' alongside Holohan when Pools won promotion from the National League in 2021 - know all about the Irishman's qualities, at 25 Wearne is nine year younger than the Crawley man. Again, the direction Pools choose to take will perhaps be indicative of their future strategy when it comes to recruitment.

Elsewhere, Pools could also look to bolster the left side of their defence, although Cameron John's return from suspension looks set to provide them with a significant boost in that regard. With winger Ashley Nathaniel-George having returned to parent-club York following the conclusion of his decidedly underwhelming month-long loan spell, all the signs suggest Pools are keen to focus on strengthening their attacking options.

While Hartlepool United fans are likely to give Smith time to settle in and implement his own ideas before passing judgement on his ownership, the success or failure of this season could well hinge on his willingness to support Featherstone in the transfer market as Pools look to propel themselves towards the play-off places.

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice