York City manager delivers verdict on Cameron John's Hartlepool United loan deal

York City manager Stuart Maynard has admitted he expects defender Cameron John to remain at Hartlepool United for the remainder of the season.

Maynard sparked fears among Pools fans that York could be set to recall the hugely popular loanee after the Minstermen boss revealed he was monitoring John "very closely".

While John, who signed on a season-long loan for Pools in July, is believed to have a January recall clause in his deal, the Hartlepool Mail understands that both clubs would have had to agree for it to be triggered.

The news will come as a big boost to Pools, with John having been one of their outstanding performers so far this season.

The versatile defender has been arguably Hartlepool United's outstanding performer this season, scoring twice in 25 appearances. Picture by Frank Reid.placeholder image
The versatile defender has been arguably Hartlepool United's outstanding performer this season, scoring twice in 25 appearances. Picture by Frank Reid.

The 26-year-old, who can operate at left-back or centre-half, has featured in all but three of his side's matches this season - John was unable to play against his parent club when Pools were beaten by York in October, while he was ineligible for their two FA Cup ties against Northern Premier League Premier Division outfit Gainsborough Trinity - and has impressed with his versatility, reliability and reading of the game.

Indeed, many Pools fans might well feel as though the former Wolves, Doncaster and Rochdale man has been their player of the season so far. John has slotted seamlessly in at centre-half, lining up either as part of a central two or on the left of a three, while he's also shown what he can do from a more forward-thinking full-back role, scoring a superb goal in November's win over Eastleigh.

At the time, John's arrival at Victoria Park went somewhat under the radar, particularly given the fact that it coincided with the departure of long-serving attacker Joe Grey, who left to join the Minstermen - despite some initial speculation, it has since been confirmed that the deals were unrelated.

Yet Pools fans shouldn't have been too surprised by John's excellent form, with the defender boasting considerable National League experience and having featured 34 times for a York side who finished second last term, missing out on promotion to the Football League despite amassing a whopping 96 points.

This season, however, John has been displaced by former Pools defender Mark Kitching, who signed for York over the summer having helped Oldham win promotion to League Two via the National League play-offs last term.

Pools fans will be relieved at the prospect of being able to call on John for the remainder of the campaign, especially given the fact that Nicky Featherstone's side are short of options on the left side of defence. Besart Topallaj, who signed on loan from Bromley in the summer, returned to his parent club last week and has since sealed a permanent move to Sutton, leaving Pools with little in the way of cover and competition at left-back.

Pools will now be hoping that John can play an integral role in their pursuit of a National League play-off place, while York are three points behind leaders Carlisle in the race for the title.

"I think he'll end up staying at Hartlepool," Maynard told BBC York.

"I think he'll end up staying there."

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice