Hartlepool United player ratings after dismal FA Cup defeat against Marine

Hartlepool United suffered a home defeat against National League North club Marine.

Hartlepool United’s season of woe found a new low as Pete Wild’s side were dumped out of the FA Cup fourth qualifying round for the fourth consecutive season as they suffered a home defeat against Marine.

Goals from Jack Doyle and James Potter gave the Merseyside outfit a famous win at Victoria Park and they will now take their place in Monday’s first round draw.

The Mail hands out our playing ratings after Pools’ latest FA Cup fourth qualifying round defeat as Pools fans suffered further disappointment on their home patch.

Hartlepool United player ratings after Marine FA Cup defeat

Neo Eccleston in action during Hartlepool United's FA Cup fourth qualifying round tie against Marine (photo Chris Fryatt)placeholder image
Neo Eccleston in action during Hartlepool United's FA Cup fourth qualifying round tie against Marine (photo Chris Fryatt) | Chris Fryatt

Max Thompson - 5

Probably couldn’t do anything about either goal but looked nervous in possession.

Reiss McNally - 5

Didn’t look like his usual composed self.

Brooklyn Ilunga - 5

Didn’t really get going and failed to provide any threat down the left-hand side.

Jordan Hugill - 5

Battled away at the top end of the pitch and tried to impose himself on Marine. Didn’t really happen for the striker but he was unlucky with a header early in the second half.

Neo Eccleston - 7

Was given a test by the lively Fin Sinclair-Smith - but more than matched the Marine winger and provided a driving threat from full back.

Nathan Sheron - 6

Worked hard in midfield and remained disciplined throughout the game.

Jack Nolan - 4

Much like a number of his team-mates, starting well but struggled to make an impact as the game wore on.

Chris Popov - 5

Had a couple of early opportunities and tried to provide energy without too much success.

Cole Deeming - 6

Looks so composed in possession as he tried to give Pools some control in midfield.

Max Clark - 6

Looks like a solid addition at left-back with a strong defensive display and a willingness to try and get forward.

Sam Lavelle - 7

A really composed debut from the on-loan defender as he looked commanding alongside McNally.

Subs

Miley (on for Popov) - 4

Tried to get on the ball to turn the tide as the visitors got on top but couldn’t make an impact.

Harris (on for Hugill) - 4

Didn’t receive the service he requires and couldn’t get involved barring one chance.

Bondo (on for Ilunga) - 4

Looks very short of confidence - but did provide a positive moment by forcing a late save out of McIntyre

John (on for Clark) - 4

Didn’t really get involved.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice